Skip to content

Review remediation and live acceptance — 2026-10-23

Historical evidence for fix/cli-tui-review, based on 83808d8a plus the review-remediation working tree. These results are bounded smoke checks, not a claim that every UI interaction, provider or failure mode has been verified.

Deterministic verification

The final applicable .NET coverage totals 7,679 passing tests across 13 projects: 4,515 in the first eleven projects, 1,369 Host tests and 1,795 GUI tests. Host approval fixtures were corrected to use a real harmless failing command instead of nonexistent executables; missing executables now have separate named-denial coverage. The last product change affected only GUI task observation and was verified with the complete GUI project and a fresh Release build.

Commands: scripts/test_dotnet.ps1 -Configuration Debug and focused complete runs with -ProjectFilter RuBackend.Tests / -ProjectFilter gui-winui3; dotnet build gui-winui3/RuApp.csproj -c Release -r win-x64 -p:Platform=x64 -p:SelfContained=true completed with zero warnings/errors. Earlier GUI gate compilation and obsolete-fixture failures were retained and investigated.

Python previously passed 210 tests with one POSIX-only skip. The TypeScript SDK passed 63 tests, typecheck and build. Route validation reported 46 HTTP routes and no WebSocket routes; runtime-boundary, Ruff and dependency checks passed.

Native UI and real provider

Acceptance used an isolated temporary data/log/workspace root, normal WinUI production composition, a current-checkout Host and the Release GUI. Existing provider credentials were consumed by the product credential store, not read into fixtures or written to evidence. Global provider settings were unchanged.

  • Settings' real connection test succeeded with OpenRouter, reporting 468 models at the time of the check.
  • Two independent real runs pinned models.dev:openrouter, nvidia/nemotron-3.5-lightning:free, chat_completions. Both completed: one called read on the acceptance file and returned its exact marker in a Vietnamese/English answer; the other returned the exact requested Vietnamese sentence. No provider/model fallback was used.
  • Native UI Automation observed the provider API-key input disabled during Back/save/load and enabled again afterwards. Property-change events alone initially missed the brief transition; direct sampling captured it.
  • Opening a retained session displayed its real conversation. A prompt submitted with the GUI composer/Send button received the exact requested answer.
  • The GUI Stop button canceled the exact newly submitted run; the Host reported cancelled with the cancelled terminal code.
  • Native inspection exposed endless task-status retries for a retained or tool-free run without a live gateway. The Host's named unavailable response remains intact. GUI feedback now retains uncertainty without perpetual idle retries; known running tasks remain visible and continue polling. The new regression failed before the fix, then all 1,795 GUI tests passed. The rebuilt Release UI displayed the corrected status and completed another real turn.

Closing the GUI shuts down its attached Host. During restart investigation an older repository publish was selected automatically; final native acceptance explicitly attached the current-checkout Host before launching the GUI. No claim is made about that older package. No installer/update acceptance, exhaustive model-quality benchmark or broad latency measurement was performed.

Local raw evidence: %TEMP%/ru-review-live-20261023/ (native screenshots, gate-result.json, live event receipts, conversations, cancellation result, GUI regression/full-test and Release logs). Earlier remediation logs and ru-review-remediation-20261023.md are in the temporary directory. Credentials are absent from the committed report.

Integration into dev

The integration combines dev at b8a42b41 (MCP, trusted Stop hooks and image reads) with review/CLI work through cf40b1d8. Executor conflict resolution retains both ImageInputAccepted and the Broker-only canonical terminal intent; the changelog retains both branches' entries. Broker documentation was aligned with the composed MCP tool and image reads.

On the merged tree, the complete .NET matrix passed 7,741 tests across thirteen projects. Python passed 210 tests with one POSIX-only skip; the route contract and runtime-boundary checks passed. GUI Release built with zero warnings/errors. Logs: %TEMP%/ru-merge-dev-dotnet.log, ru-merge-dev-python.log and ru-merge-dev-release.log. These deterministic merge checks are separate from the earlier native UI/provider acceptance on the review branch.